This is a long-brewing responce to many politicians... Democrat politicians. This is a responce to Tipper, to Leiberman, to Hilliary, and to every single other politician that has used poplular culture as a way out. As a way to define themselves when they have nothing else to say. As a way to gather attention and support from lazy parents who think it's the record companies' fault their kids are listening to Rap or Heavy Metal instead of thier own. So when those kids do drugs, those parents can have someone to blame... other than themselves.
Those politicians are shooting themselves in the foot by raging against not only a lost cause, but a bullshit one.
Let's start with the obvious -- the only time the politicians care about any of this is when it sells to white kids. That's right. White kids.
Rock and Roll? It wasn't invented by Elvis, but when Elvis shook his pelvis, politicians RAGED.
NWA -- "Niggas Wit Attitude" for the unenlightened. So, NWA? No problem; let the darkies have their music.... that is until they started selling millions of albums to middle-America white kids.
Remember Ice T's "Copkiller" album? He rode the white-teenage-middle-class of hardcore-rap-buyers that NWA created. Remember the "outrage" of politicians? (NOTE: this is when Tipper started her campaign.) Yeah, it had nothing to do with the fear of blacks shooting cops. It had to do with anti-establishment sentiments that had actually taken hold in white kids that had never seen a ghetto, let alone ever thought about shooting a cop. (But, in fairness, they all probably owned shotguns... thanks, second amendment!!!)
The key word in the last sentence was "ideas". Those idiot politicians were fighting against teenage rebellion. Something that was unheard of before a middle-class was created in America (back when you were either too poor or too rich to be a rebel), but grew throughout this century, and is currently peaking with the post-Baby Boomer generations. You've got a bunch of spoiled kids that are dissatisfied with what they have, while at the same time they don't respect what they have.
I'm not critisizing them, mind you, I am one of them. Ah, life in the middle class. Nothing is good enough for us.
So, this is the post for all those who think that RAP is killing our moral values and the literal fabric of our society.
I remember the first time a tape (that's right -- "tape") was taken away from me by my parents. It was "G'N'R Lies". I think it was because a naked lady was on the cover. I'm 28 (just 28 today actually), but when I was in fourth grade, I memorized Slash's riffs on air guitar... think I listened to that tape about 60 nights in a row (before it was taken away from me). I can't describe to you how good it felt to hear someone expressing the (unfounded) anger I possesed. Axl Rose was PISSED and he belted his lyrics like I'd never imagine anyone actually speaking. Slash spoke with his guitar. Adler banged his drums as if he was going to die right after each song. Guns 'N Roses were my Gods. And honestly, I had no idea what they were singing about half of the time. Listening to Mr. Brownstone years later... yeah, ok, it's about heroin. When I was young, the only thing I heard in that song was aggresion. And that's all that mattered. They were pissed, and they talked to the world for me.
But what Axl was to me, Lennon and Jagger were to my parents, as I'm sure Eminem was to 4th graders a few years ago.
And to be honest, I can't wait for what my future kids listen to. It won't be something I approve of, but I would like to think that I'd at least respect it for what it will be to them -- a way to defy convention, and break away from me. I'd rather them act out their agression through music or video games, or whatever is the medium at the time, than to act on what I consider even more harmful things.
Axl talked about screwing whores, shooting herion, and getting arrested like they were badges. I never did any of these things, and I like to think that my parents were a strong factor in that.
I got to live THROUGH my rock heroes, and get out aggrestion by listening to their songs. But I was taught right from wrong, and I knew the difference between real and Nintendo (or PS2 if you will).
A ton of pop culture is aimed at kids, and kids eat it up becuase it is an escape that they need. Just like Horror Comics in the 30s and 40s, or Elvis in the 50s. The real test is what type of influence the parents have on the kids. Keep in mind, both Horror Comics (like EC) and Elvis brought about legistlaion concerning the "corruption of youth".
And not to get political, but both Dems and Repubs want to legislate pop culture... distracting the public from real problems -- while they are doing nothing to cure poverty, which is the true culprit of most blue collar crime (and they turn a blind eye to greed, which is the culprit of most white collar crime). Hell, the only reason we have rock or rap is govenment's blind eye to inequality.
How many crimes are commited strictly because of pop culture? I'd say none. None at all. Crimes are commited out of desperation and greed and lack of sympathy for victims. Does pop culture give future criminals ideas? Absolutely. But criminals will commit crimes regardless of what songs they've listened to.... and I'd wager there was far more rampant crime and aggression during Bach's time than ours.
Let's face it... we as Americans are enlightened. Well, most of the time (NOTE: I do not count Dick Cheney's willingness to torture people enlightment). Crime has gone down every year since Clinton took office (yes, even during the Bush Jr. years). We have a decently strong middle class that has great values. And no matter how many murders you hear sensationalized on FOX News, the murder rate is way, way down.
And yet, you have politicians preaching the end of moral values because of pop culture.
I call them idiots who are emotionally retarded. They talk about fake sex and violence as if they were real. And to call any music or video games to task regarding violence when you can plainly see graphic murders and violence on CSI, CSI:Miami, CSI:NY, Law & Order (all 18 of them), Bones, Ultimate Fighting, Boxing, ER, Killer Instinct, and top it off with casual sex on Desperate Houseives, is plainly and disgustingly disingenuous.
But then again... kids can't vote. And adults always - ALWAYS - seem to forget what it was like to be a teen.
If the worst I have to deal with is a long-haired kid in my basement who listens to music too loud, then I'll be a happy man.
But then again, by the time I have kids, I may have forgotten I wrote this, and I'll be the one condemning MTV and the XBox.